[ This is probably the single most "I'm done with your shit" thing that Atsumu has ever seen Gray do, and he looks genuinely surprised by her deciding to silence her weapon friend there. Surprised, and mildly impressed, but not yet soothed from the offense he feels at this rejection from someone he wasn't actually romantically interested in to begin with.

Though her comment does give him pause, and he frowns as he considers what that could even mean. ]

What kinda unusual preference?

[ Is she like the people who are kind of delusional and only want to date cartoon people? Some kind of furry? What's up here?

The more mundane conclusion doesn't even occur to him, because that seems too normal to even classify as unusual. ]

Like only into huge bald guys unusual? Or one of those people who is real weird about feet?